It may be just me, but I liked the overview over the blog posts better. I'm almost exclusively on the forum, so it was nice to see when new blog posts where available. The 25 last changes take up considerably more space and are less useful in my opinion, since the forum is quite fast-paced at times - blog posts are likely to get lost in the bulk of forum posts. No biggie, I have the blog and blog comments in my RSS reader anyway, so I won't miss anything.
But I did add the last changes box to my proxy filter, it's just taking up to much space for my taste. I admit I'm a control-freak, I like to adjust web sites to the way I use them. This page now looks like this for me: http://andreashofmann.info/public/images/1267308856717.png
I removed the twitter, grader and amazon content pretty early on, because it would load really slow for me, plus I already follow Mark on twitter and bought those of his books I can afford (i.e. everything but Dreams). Then I removed the whole right sidebar so I won't have horizontal scrollbars on my (sub-)notebook.
Mark, I hope you don't mind that I'm tinkering that much with your page, even if the changes are only on my own PC.
I also prefer to have the blog posts highlighted. I am always checking the Forum anyway, but only look at the Blog if I see there is a new post in the left column.
I agree with Andreas and Wooba. Having a separate overview for new blog posts was better (and ideally it should also include new comments). One for forum posts may be useful, as long as it's separated from the blog posts, but not really necessary since the forum ist always shows threads with new posts on the top, anyway. And it's only one forum without subforums, so not a lot there to aggregate.
My stand point is the current list is already sorted by last modification dates. I personnaly don't see any added value in duplicating in the left column the same information. IMHO.
One more thing I just noticed: The rather extensive list of post updates makes the left column overly long. Because of that, when you use the "go to bottom of page" keyboard shortcut (in my case, Cmd - Down, in Windows, Ctrl - End), as I usually do to get to the newest posts of a thread, you'll always have to scroll back up quite a bit. That's a little invonvenient.
The general feeling seems to be that it would be best not to include forum comments. So I will set it so that it will show blog post, comments and all other changes to the site apart from the forum. I will also experiment with the best length.
It is, of course, Mark's site for him to do as he wishes, but I'll just throw in a vote for restoring new blog posts to a high-status position in the left hand bar, not mixed in with new blog comments. In terms of this site and its audience, a new blog post from Mark is surely MUCH more important, relatively speaking, than any one new blog comment — it's certainly what I always check for. Of course, I could bookmark the blog and check that rather than (or as well as) the forum, but posts from Mark are sufficiently rare that this would be a waste of daily clicking. Like most of the people who follow Mark the most closely, I assume, I bookmark the forum, check it (because there's always SOMETHING new, whether interesting or not) and glance over to the left to see whether we have also been graced with that rarer occurrence, a new blog post.
I like the "new posts" and "new comments" sections on the sidebar. They're a nice addition to the twitter updates section. I was easily able to see which of your blog posts had comments I hadn't read (though the links brought me to the original post rather than the newest comment).
Instead of highlighting Norman's posts, could you add an option to highlight the posts that match a username that we could type into a text box in your Userscript Options area?
So I would want to highlight all posts matching "Brian", etc. Possible?
-David
But I did add the last changes box to my proxy filter, it's just taking up to much space for my taste. I admit I'm a control-freak, I like to adjust web sites to the way I use them. This page now looks like this for me: http://andreashofmann.info/public/images/1267308856717.png
I removed the twitter, grader and amazon content pretty early on, because it would load really slow for me, plus I already follow Mark on twitter and bought those of his books I can afford (i.e. everything but Dreams). Then I removed the whole right sidebar so I won't have horizontal scrollbars on my (sub-)notebook.
Mark, I hope you don't mind that I'm tinkering that much with your page, even if the changes are only on my own PC.
That's what I would prefer. :-)
Norman: Sorry, I don't have the option just to highlight your posts - though I'm sure it would be just great if I could.
1) The New Posts section will also show any new pages or amendments to pages on the site.
2) I've made the New Comments section twice as long as the New Posts section as comments are more frequent.
Mark: <<Sorry, I don't have the option just to highlight your posts -
though I'm sure it would be just great if I could. >>
Well, I can. ;-)
I modified my userscript at http://andreashofmann.net/userscripts/markforster.net/ to include a "highlight Norman's posts" option.
Here's what it looks like in action: http://andreashofmann.info/public/images/1267482957165.png
Norman, would you prefer a different color?
Thanks.
No problem, I updated the script again: http://andreashofmann.info/public/images/1267484301061.png
It does make the forum kinda more manageable ...
My only suggestion would be to change the highlight color of Norman's posts to black...
Didn't see your reply at first because you're not Norman, but anyway, I updated the script once again: http://andreashofmann.info/public/images/1267485610914.png
I decided to move these option in the appropriately named category 'best sense'.
Sorry, but it wouldn't be fair to only implement your suggestions and not those of others. :-)
Instead of highlighting Norman's posts, could you add an option to highlight the posts that match a username that we could type into a text box in your Userscript Options area?
So I would want to highlight all posts matching "Brian", etc. Possible?